Co-Parenting at Christmas: What Happens When Parents Can’t Agree?

Co-Parenting at Christmas: What Happens When Parents Can’t Agree?

Practical guidance for separated parents managing holiday arrangements, family expectations and children’s wellbeing.

Christmas morning. Two homes. And one very difficult question: where will the children wake up?

For separated parents, Christmas can bring decisions that aren’t always easy to make. Will the children see both parents on Christmas Day? What happens when grandparents or extended whānau have their own celebrations planned?

For some families, this may be their first Christmas living apart. For others, arrangements that worked in previous years may no longer suit their children’s needs or changing circumstances.

Christmas might look different after separation, but it can still be a special time for children. Finding arrangements that work takes planning, flexibility and sometimes a little support.

 

When Christmas means different things to each parent

Christmas can carry strong emotional significance. One parent may have always hosted Christmas lunch, while the other values spending Christmas morning opening presents with the children.

Sometimes the disagreement isn’t really about the number of hours. It’s about missing Christmas morning, letting go of a treasured family tradition, or wondering what Christmas will look like from now on.

Recognising these feelings can help parents understand why a seemingly simple discussion about dates and times has become difficult.

And while both parents’ feelings matter, keeping children’s wellbeing at the centre of the conversation can help everyone focus on what matters most.

 

Christmas does not have to look the same in both homes

One of the challenges of co-parenting is accepting that family celebrations may change.

Children may have Christmas breakfast in one household and a family gathering in another. Some families may alternate Christmas Day each year, while others celebrate on separate dates.

There is no single right way to celebrate Christmas across two households. What matters is whether the arrangement is appropriate for the children, practical for those involved and consistent with any relevant Parenting Agreements or Parenting orders.

Parents may also find it helpful to consider how much travelling children are expected to do. Moving repeatedly between households on Christmas Day can be tiring, especially for younger children or those travelling longer distances.

Sometimes, fewer transitions and more relaxed time together can make the holiday more enjoyable.

New traditions can also develop naturally. A special Christmas Eve dinner, a Boxing Day outing or a family celebration later in December can become just as meaningful as Christmas Day itself.

Grandparents and extended whānau can also play an important role. Being flexible about when and how family celebrations happen can help reduce pressure on parents and give children more opportunities to enjoy time with the people they love.

 

Start planning before December arrives

Christmas arrangements can become more stressful when decisions are left until the last minute, especially when work commitments, travel, school holidays and wider family plans all need to be considered.

  • Where will the children spend Christmas Eve, Christmas Day and Boxing Day?
  • Will time be shared between households, or will celebrations take place on different days?
  • Are there travel plans or extended family gatherings to consider?
  • How and when will children move between households?
  • What happens if plans change unexpectedly?
  • How will parents communicate important information during the holidays?

The New Zealand Ministry of Justice provides guidance on agreeing to parenting arrangements, including the importance of considering children’s needs. [1]

If there is an existing Parenting Agreement or Parenting Order, parents should review what it says about Christmas and holiday arrangements. Any proposed changes should be considered carefully, particularly where a Court Order applies.

Putting agreed arrangements in writing can also help reduce misunderstandings and provide greater certainty for everyone involved.

 

Put children’s experiences at the centre of Christmas

For children, Christmas after separation may feel exciting, confusing or emotionally difficult, sometimes all at once.

They may look forward to spending time with both parents while also feeling sad that familiar traditions have changed.

What matters most to children may also be quite different from what the adults are focused on. While parents are working out dates, travel and how to share Christmas Day, children may simply be thinking about seeing their cousins, visiting grandparents or enjoying their favourite traditions.

Listening to children matters, but they shouldn’t feel responsible for choosing between their parents. Rather than asking where they would prefer to spend Christmas, parents can ask what they are most looking forward to and what would help make the holidays enjoyable for them.

This child-focused approach is also reflected in New Zealand law. Section 4 of the Care of Children Act 2004 places children’s welfare and best interests at the centre of decisions about their care. [2][2] Under section 6 of the Care of Children Act 2004, children must be given reasonable opportunities to express their views in proceedings involving their care, and those views must be taken into account. [3]

Understanding what matters to children can help parents create arrangements that support their needs without placing them in the middle of adult disagreements.

 

What happens when parents cannot agree?

Even with the best intentions, some parents may struggle to reach an agreement.

One parent may want to travel overseas with the children, while the other has concerns about the proposed arrangements. Parents may disagree about how Christmas Day should be divided, or communication may have become so difficult that productive conversations are no longer are not currently possible.

When discussions repeatedly lead to conflict, continuing the same conversation may not bring families any closer to a solution.

When you’ve had the same conversation over and over and still can’t find a way forward, having someone independent help you work through the options can make a real difference. That’s where family mediation may help.

Mediation provides a structured, confidential process in which an independent mediator supports parents to discuss their concerns, understand different perspectives and explore possible arrangements.

The mediator does not take sides or decide who should have the children at Christmas. Instead, the process helps parents work towards practical, child-focused agreements.

For example, mediation may help parents explore different ways to share holiday time, agree on travel and handover arrangements, or establish clearer expectations for communication.

Mediation is not suitable in every situation, particularly where safety concerns or family violence may affect a person’s ability to participate safely. Professional advice and appropriate safeguards are important in these circumstances.

Where an existing Parenting Order is involved, parents should also understand their legal obligations. The Ministry of Justice provides guidance on Parenting Orders and what happens when an order is not followed. [4]

 

How FDRC can help families move forward

At the Family Dispute Resolution Centre (FDRC), we know that disagreements about parenting arrangements can be difficult, especially at a time of year when everyone wants Christmas to be special for their children.

Our private parenting and guardianship mediation services help separated parents work through care arrangements, co-parenting communication and other decisions affecting their children.

With the support of an independent mediator and a dedicated case manager, parents can explore practical options in a structured environment, with a focus on children’s wellbeing and arrangements that work in everyday life.

Where appropriate, FDRC also offers Voice of the Child services, Development Consultations and Preparation for Mediation Coaching to support families through the process.

Children’s perspectives can be an important part of resolving parenting disagreements. FDRC explores this further in our article, The Role of Children’s Voices in Family Dispute Resolution. [5]

 

A different Christmas can still be a meaningful one

Children don’t need a perfect Christmas. They need to feel loved, secure and free to enjoy the people who matter to them.

Christmas after separation might look different, but with a little flexibility and planning, it can still be a time of connection and happy memories.

 

Finding it difficult to agree on Christmas arrangements?

You don’t need to have all the answers before asking for help. FDRC’s independent mediators can support you in finding practical arrangements that put your children first.

Need support with parenting arrangements?

Book a free phone consultation at https://fdrc.co.nz/contact-us or call FDRC on 0508 337 236.

Find out more about Parenting and Guardianship Mediation: https://fdrc.co.nz/your-situation/parenting-and-guardianship [6]

 

Further reading and links

  1. Ministry of Justice – Agree on Parenting Arrangements https://www.justice.govt.nz/family/care-of-children/parenting-arrangements/agree-on-parenting-arrangements/
  2. Care of Children Act 2004 – Section 4 https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2004/90/en/latest/sections/DLM317240/
  3. Care of Children Act 2004 – Section 6 https://www.legislation.govt.nz/act/public/2004/90/en/latest/sections/DLM317946/
  4. Ministry of Justice – Enforce a Court Order https://www.justice.govt.nz/family/care-of-children/court-orders/enforce-a-court-order/
  5. FDRC – The Role of Children’s Voices in Family Dispute Resolution https://fdrc.co.nz/knowledge-hub/the-role-of-childrens-voices-in-family-dispute-resolution
  6. FDRC – Parenting and Guardianship Mediation https://fdrc.co.nz/your-situation/parenting-and-guardianship

This article provides general information and is not intended as legal advice. Families should seek independent legal advice about their particular circumstances where appropriate.

Other resources you might like

Elder Mediation Specialist Accreditation: Gerard Sullivan

Elder Mediation Specialist Accreditation: Gerard Sullivan

When Wealth Planning Meets Family Conflict: Why Trusts and Estate Disputes Need More Than a Lawyer

When Wealth Planning Meets Family Conflict: Why Trusts and Estate Disputes Need More Than a Lawyer